When a SaaS product shuts down, its directory listings should no longer invite visitors to sign up. For each public page, check what it says and where its product link goes. Keep an accurate page that leads to useful closure information; request a correction if the page is misleading; request removal if an accurate page or useful destination is not feasible. The publisher decides which changes it permits.
Find the pages visitors can still reach
Make a short working record for each public listing: its URL, displayed description or status, product-link destination, available account access, desired change, and the result of your last public check. Open the page rather than treating a submitted listing as a live one. Search for the product name as well, so pages created outside your team's submission records are not overlooked.
If your team used Ranks, its submission history shows where the product was submitted, which submissions await approval, and which listings are live. Saved listing logins are accessible when available. Use those records to find pages and investigate access; they do not give you authority to change a publisher's page.
Before asking any directory to replace a product link, publish the destination you intend visitors to reach. A useful closure page states that the product is no longer available, gives an accurate shutdown date or current status, and tells existing users where to find any applicable account, data, billing or support information. Include only promises your team can still honor. Then test the closure page directly; do not send publishers a proposed URL that still leads to the old signup flow.
Choose what each listing should say
The goal is not necessarily to erase every historical mention. A page can remain useful if visitors immediately understand that the product has closed and its link leads to a working notice. Use the public page and destination—not just your ability to sign in—to make the decision.
Product Hunt illustrates why a correction and a removal request are different paths. Its guidance says owners and members can edit Page content, but fields absent from settings require a request to its team. Separately, Product Hunt says it has no self-service product deletion, removal requests go to its team, and posts about products that no longer exist may remain as a record of community discussion. Check the actual options offered by each publisher; Product Hunt's rules are not universal directory policy.
Here is a fictional decision. A discontinued app, Northstar, has a working notice at https://northstar.example/closure. Directory A already links there, but its description still says “Start your free trial.” Ask for the description to say the product has closed; keep the page if the correction appears publicly. Directory B links to a dead signup page. Ask it to replace the link with the closure URL and correct the description. If it cannot make the page accurate and usable, ask whether it will remove the listing. Neither request is complete until the public result is checked.
| What visitors see | Action to take | Acceptable outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Closure is clear; link reaches a working notice | Keep the listing | Public wording and destination remain accurate |
| Old signup claim, dead link or other misleading detail | Edit an available field or request a publisher correction | Public page explains closure and links to useful information |
| Publisher cannot provide an accurate page or useful destination | Request removal and ask what alternative is available | Confirm removal publicly, or record what remains unresolved |
Send a request the publisher can act on
If you can edit the relevant fields, make the change and move on to a public check. Otherwise, use the publisher's page-change or support route. On Product Hunt, the guidance directs owners and members to “request changes to this page” for fields missing from settings. Its removal guidance directs requests to the Product Hunt team; deleting your account does not automatically remove associated products.
Adapt this fictional request after the closure destination is live: “Subject: Update discontinued product listing — Northstar. I manage Northstar; the listing is at https://directory.example/products/northstar. The product has shut down, but the page currently says ‘Start your free trial’ and links to an unavailable signup page. Please replace that wording with ‘Northstar is no longer available’ and change the product link to https://northstar.example/closure. I can provide information to verify my association with the product. If these changes are not possible, please let me know whether removal is available. Could you confirm what you change so I can check the public page?” Replace every fictional detail with the listing's actual URL, observed problem, verified status and intended destination.
If removal is the only acceptable outcome for a particular page, say why a correction would not resolve the visitor's problem. Ask for a decision rather than assuming the publisher will delete the page. Keep the request and any reply with your listing record.
Verify the public page, not just the reply
After an edit or publisher response, reopen the listing as a visitor. Read the visible status and description, follow the product link, and confirm that its final destination shows the intended closure information rather than a signup, error or unrelated homepage. If removal was requested, check whether the listing URL is still publicly accessible. Record the date and result; leave the item open if the public page does not match the requested change.
A publisher may leave a historical page up even after declining removal, so separate “request answered” from “visitors accurately informed.” If the listing remains misleading, follow up with the precise discrepancy and the public URL. If the real problem is a continuing product with a new identity, use the rebrand listing-update guide; if two pages compete for the same product, use the duplicate-listings guide. A shutdown has a different end state: visitors need an honest closure message, not a replacement product profile.



